🧠 The Psychology of Why Transparent Nudges Work Better

Welcome to our latest newsletter.

This month, we look at new studies on reactions to change.

At how telling people they're being nudged makes it more effective.
 
At why we are drawn to dark content. And why people believe that behaviour can change but personalities can't.

Why bronze can feel better than silver.

And how you can apply these insights.

Do you want to nudge your way to better results?
📈 Grow your business?
💰 Sell more?
💎 Increase customer value?

Email us to see how behavioural science can help you.

Every so often we use our Monkey Business newsletter to share useful nuggets, opinions, and findings as food for thought. Sign up here.

Transparent Nudging: Why Telling People They’re Being Nudged Makes It More Effective

Nudges don’t have to be sneaky to succeed.

A recent meta-analysis of 23 studies, reported in Psychology Today, finds that behavioural nudges - such as default settings, opt-out choices, or design prompts — remain just as effective when people are told they’re being nudged. In many cases, disclosure even enhances the nudge’s impact.

Why? Because transparency builds trust. Rather than feeling manipulated, people perceive the intervention as respectful and aligned with their autonomy. They’re more likely to follow a prompt if they believe it’s there to help, not trick.

Practical Business Takeouts

Be Upfront About Nudges: Let users know when they're being guided - it boosts trust without reducing effectiveness.

Use Nudging to Empower, Not Coerce: Nudges should help users make better choices, not push them toward hidden agendas.

Disclose With Confidence: Don’t bury defaults or recommendations - explain why they’re there.

Trust Is the Real Persuader: People are more likely to follow nudges when they believe your intent is honest and helpful.

Ethics and Outcomes Aren’t Opposites: Transparency strengthens both your brand integrity and your behavioural influence.

Like this? 👉 Share it with a friend

Photo by Mart Production

The Paradox of the Podium: Why Bronze Feels Better Than Silver

Finishing third can feel like a win — finishing second can feel like a loss.

Various studies have shown that Olympic bronze medalists are often happier than silver medalists.

Why? Regret. Silver medalists tend to focus on what they missed (gold), while bronze medalists focus on what they almost lost (a place on the podium).

This is a classic example of “counterfactual thinking” — how our emotions aren’t driven by reality, but by imagined alternatives.

For brands and customer experiences, it’s a reminder: satisfaction is relative, not absolute. And a smartly framed outcome can feel far better than a technically better one.

Practical Business Takeaways

Design Experiences to Trigger Gratitude, Not Regret: Highlight what customers avoided or narrowly gained - not what they didn’t get.

Celebrate the Win That Wasn’t Guaranteed: “You beat the rush” is more emotionally satisfying than “You got standard delivery.” Frame it as a near-miss win.

Avoid Post-Purchase FOMO: Up-selling after a decision (“You could’ve had premium…”) may fuel regret instead of loyalty.

Use Tiered Outcomes to Reinforce Value: Create “good, better, best” moments - where even the mid-tier feels earned and worth celebrating.

Turn Relief Into Loyalty: Show customers what they dodged (fees, waiting, outages) - not just what they gained.

Engineer Bronze Moments: Let customers feel lucky to have made it - limited access, time-sensitive wins, or just-in-time upgrades all create emotional stickiness.

Like this? 👉 Share it with a friend

Photo by RDNE

Why People Reject New Rules – But Only Until They Take Effect

Resistance to change is often loud—but short-lived.

A recent study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences reveals that public opposition to new regulations, such as smoking bans or speed limits, tends to diminish significantly after these rules are implemented.

Researchers from the Technical University of Munich and the University of Vienna conducted seven studies across various countries, examining responses to policies like workplace smoking bans, seatbelt laws, and speed limits. They found that psychological reactance—a defensive response to perceived threats to freedom—is strongest before a policy is enacted but wanes once the new norm is established.

This shift occurs because, initially, individuals focus on personal losses (e.g., reduced freedom or comfort). However, after the policy takes effect, attention shifts toward societal benefits, such as improved public health or safety. Understanding this psychological transition can help policymakers and businesses navigate the implementation of new initiatives more effectively.

Practical Business Takeaways

Anticipate Initial Resistance: Recognise that pushback is a natural response to change but often diminishes post-implementation.

Communicate Societal Benefits Early: Emphasise the broader positive impacts of a change to shift focus from personal loss to collective gain.

Frame Changes as Enhancements: Present new policies or features as improvements rather than restrictions to reduce perceived threats to autonomy.

Leverage Social Norms: Highlight widespread acceptance or adoption to encourage conformity and reduce resistance.

Monitor and Address Concerns: Continue engaging with stakeholders post-implementation to reinforce benefits and address any lingering issues.

Like this? 👉 Share it with a friend

Photo by SHVETS

Why Grim Gets Clicks: The Strange Allure of Dark Content
People don’t just tolerate tragic stories - they’re drawn to them.

A new study from the University of Surrey explores why themes of death, danger and disaster grab our attention. The answer? Morbid curiosity. Participants showed a strong psychological pull toward dark content - not because they enjoyed it, but because it felt important, thrilling, or emotionally rich.

It’s a finding that feels counterintuitive - and commercially useful. But also: dangerous if misused.

Practical Business Takeouts

Curiosity Isn’t Always Cheerful: People are instinctively drawn to disturbing or dramatic content - especially when it hints at hidden knowledge, threat or survival.

Emotional Tension Drives Attention: Dark or tragic narratives can trigger intense engagement, but they need narrative purpose, not just shock value.

Use Sparingly - and Ethically: Dark framing can backfire if overused or seen as exploitative. Deploy it thoughtfully, and only when it connects authentically to your message.

Know Your Audience: Younger, thrill-seeking segments may be more receptive. Older or more risk-averse audiences may recoil. Test before you roll out.

Contrast Darkness with Light: The most effective use of dark themes often comes when paired with hope, resilience, or transformation -  not nihilism.

Apply to Format, Not Just Message: Visual tone, sound design or copy style can carry ‘dark energy’ in subtle ways - useful in campaigns designed to stop the scroll.

Don’t Mistake Engagement for Affection: Just because something gets clicks doesn’t mean it builds trust. Track long-term effects on perception, not just impressions.

Like this? 👉 Share it with a friend

Photo by CHATGPT

Changing Minds: Why Customers Believe Behaviours Can Shift, but Personalities Can't

People don't believe all change is the same.

A recent study reveals that individuals perceive social–emotional behaviour skills, like empathy or self-control, as more malleable than core personality traits such as extraversion or neuroticism.

Participants rated social-emotional behaviour skills as both more desirable and more feasible to change, indicating a belief that behaviours are within one's control, whereas personality traits are seen as fixed. This distinction has significant implications for how consumers perceive personal growth, change, and the effectiveness of interventions

Practical Business Takeouts

Frame Change as Behavioural, Not Personal: When encouraging customers to adopt new habits or use your product, emphasise changes in behaviour rather than personality transformation.

Highlight Skill Development: Position your offerings as tools to develop specific skills (e.g., "Improve your communication skills") rather than altering inherent traits.

Set Achievable Goals: Design programs or campaigns that focus on small, attainable behavioural changes to increase perceived feasibility.

Use Testimonials Wisely: Share success stories that showcase behavioural improvements, reinforcing the idea that change is possible and desirable.

Educate About Malleability: Inform your audience that certain behaviours can be developed over time, countering the belief that personal attributes are unchangeable.

Tailor Messaging to Audience Beliefs: Understand your target audience's perceptions of change and customise your messaging to align with their beliefs about personal development.

Don't Overpromise: Be careful not to promise complete personality overhauls; focus instead on realistic behavioural enhancements to maintain credibility.

Like this? 👉 Share it with a friend

Photo by Kaboompics

😓 Tough business challenge? See if we can help. We probably can.

James, Patrick and Dan

capuchin.cc

We practically apply the science of the human mind for hard, commercial results 

Please feel free to share.
➡️ Sign up for your own MONKEY BUSINESS by clicking here